PAVE is an athlete marketplace and mentorship platform that connects aspiring youth athletes and their parents with college and professional athletes, known as PavePros, for 1:1 video calls, messaging, and guidance on recruiting, development, and NIL.
A two-sided marketplace only works when both sides grow. Beyond reaching families, PAVE needed a steady supply of credible college and pro athletes signing up as PavePros, and it needed paid media that could prove it was driving real app downloads, not just clicks.



How PAVE Achieved a 32% Lower Cost Per Download with Athlete Whitelisting
337K+
Campaign Impressions
386
App Downloads
$6.79
Cost per Download
The Brand

The challenge
Scaling a youth sports marketplace through paid social presented unique challenges:
• Proving real conversions: PAVE needed paid spend tied to app downloads and sign-ups, not just traffic and impressions
• Finding the right creative: it was unclear whether athlete-voiced whitelisted ads or athlete UGC would perform better with a high-intent audience
• Reaching the supply side: growing the marketplace meant convincing college and pro athletes, a hard-to-target audience, to download the app and join as PavePros
PAVE needed a partner who could build the paid social infrastructure from scratch, pair it with authentic athlete creative, and optimize toward measurable app growth.
• Proving real conversions: PAVE needed paid spend tied to app downloads and sign-ups, not just traffic and impressions
• Finding the right creative: it was unclear whether athlete-voiced whitelisted ads or athlete UGC would perform better with a high-intent audience
• Reaching the supply side: growing the marketplace meant convincing college and pro athletes, a hard-to-target audience, to download the app and join as PavePros
PAVE needed a partner who could build the paid social infrastructure from scratch, pair it with authentic athlete creative, and optimize toward measurable app growth.
The ask
PAVE partnered with MOGL to launch an Athlete Paid Social (APS) program on Meta and:
1) Stand up PAVE's full Meta advertising and tracking infrastructure
2) Drive high-intent traffic to the PAVE sign-up page at market-leading rates
3) Test athlete whitelisting against athlete UGC head-to-head to find the winning creative
4) Convert college and professional athletes into PAVE app downloads at an efficient cost per download
Primary audience: College and professional athletes (18–34) joining as PavePros, following an initial phase focused on sports parents (35–50) and aspiring youth athletes (14–18)
1) Stand up PAVE's full Meta advertising and tracking infrastructure
2) Drive high-intent traffic to the PAVE sign-up page at market-leading rates
3) Test athlete whitelisting against athlete UGC head-to-head to find the winning creative
4) Convert college and professional athletes into PAVE app downloads at an efficient cost per download
Primary audience: College and professional athletes (18–34) joining as PavePros, following an initial phase focused on sports parents (35–50) and aspiring youth athletes (14–18)
The Solution
MOGL built a two-phase athlete paid social program on Meta, first proving athlete creative could drive traffic below target costs, then shifting to a conversion campaign optimized for app downloads.
Program structure
• 4 college athletes from MOGL's network across two campaign phases, each phase pairing one whitelisted athlete with one athlete UGC creator
• Deliverables: 4 athlete video assets run as paid Meta ads
• Content: Athletes speaking in their own voice about PAVE and the value of mentorship from athletes who have been there
Creative approach
• Head-to-head testing of whitelisted athlete ads vs. boosted athlete UGC, with each ad set running a single creative for a clean comparison
• Shifted creative and placements toward Instagram Reels, which drove ~82% of conversions
Program structure
• 4 college athletes from MOGL's network across two campaign phases, each phase pairing one whitelisted athlete with one athlete UGC creator
• Deliverables: 4 athlete video assets run as paid Meta ads
• Content: Athletes speaking in their own voice about PAVE and the value of mentorship from athletes who have been there
Creative approach
• Head-to-head testing of whitelisted athlete ads vs. boosted athlete UGC, with each ad set running a single creative for a clean comparison
• Shifted creative and placements toward Instagram Reels, which drove ~82% of conversions
The Results


The program delivered PAVE's primary objective, measurable athlete acquisition through paid social, beating traffic targets in Phase 1 and driving 386 app downloads in Phase 2 at a $6.79 cost per download, 32% below the $10 industry benchmark.
PAVE's internal sign-up data lined up directly with campaign activity, with daily sign-ups scaling as spend increased.
PAVE's internal sign-up data lined up directly with campaign activity, with daily sign-ups scaling as spend increased.
Performance Metrics
App Downloads: 386
Cost per Download: $6.79
Campaign Impressions: 337,373
Cost per Click: $0.42
Cost per Download: $6.79
Campaign Impressions: 337,373
Cost per Click: $0.42
Top Performing Athlete
Brooke Mcloy (whitelisted ad): 203 app downloads, $0.73 CPC, 1.66% CTR